Hayley Matz Meadvin is an govt vp of communications at Precision Methods. She beforehand served as senior adviser to the U.S. training secretary and chief of technique and communications for Chicago Public Faculties.
Republicans railing towards the U.S. Division of Training is a story as outdated as time. Ronald Reagan vowed to abolish it, and since his presidency there’s been no scarcity of Republican legislative and presidential candidates who’ve referred to as for it to be eradicated. President-elect Donald Trump additionally introduced his want to eradicate the division, a coverage aim he has repeated since his victory in November.
With Republicans in command of the White Home, Home and Senate, it’s not exterior the realm of chance that this drastic proposal might come to fruition.
However Trump prides himself on standing exterior the political orthodoxy of both occasion. Eliminating the Training Division feels extra like an old-school Republican trope, and there’s a greater play the president-elect could make. As a grasp of branding, he ought to see the chance to rebrand the Training Division as a substitute of eliminating it.
Hayley Matz Meadvin
Permission granted by Hayley Matz Meadvin
As a senior adviser to the U.S. training secretary within the Biden administration, I’ve seen firsthand the division’s potential to assist drive America’s financial competitiveness. Trump ought to reimagine the Training Division because the Division of American Competitiveness.
The driving pressure behind Republican opposition to the Training Division has all the time been the concern that it will infringe on states and localities’ skill to set their very own tutorial curricula. Native management over Ok-12 training is a bedrock conservative worth. Nevertheless, over the Division’s many years of existence — underneath each Democratic and Republican administrations — this concern has by no means been realized.
The division’s remit has remained constant through the years, setting a nationwide imaginative and prescient for our colleges and college students. It usually gives carrots and sticks to assist them get there, from No Youngster Left Behind underneath President George W. Bush to Widespread Core underneath President Barack Obama. The company additionally performs a key function in some important areas, together with supplemental funding for underserved college districts and particular teaching programs, and administering pupil loans for school college students.
Eliminating the Training Division can be symbolic greater than anything. No matter you consider President-elect Trump, he has branded himself as a catalyst of sweeping transformation. Remodeling the nation and competing on a worldwide scale requires, amongst different issues, a nationwide innovation technique that begins with rethinking the pre-Kindergarten by faculty training system.
If the Trump administration is severe about competing with China, tariffs gained’t tackle the underlying proven fact that the U.S. is falling behind on expertise coaching. The nation doesn’t have a coherent training technique for science, know-how, engineering and math fields, and as synthetic intelligence quickly evolves, the talents wanted for the U.S. to stay the worldwide tech chief will evolve simply as shortly.
No federal company is tasked with main this effort. Why not unleash tech leaders on the duty of figuring out and operationalizing the constructing blocks we have to make the U.S. the world’s know-how powerhouse? This remit would construct on the Training Division’s present work and encourage massive pondering that transcends politics.
The Training Division, because the Division of American Competitiveness, can be positioned to chop by the paperwork and set up nationwide priorities.
We proved this because the U.S. got here out of the pandemic. Mother and father had been annoyed by the patchwork of insurance policies between states and wanted sturdy federal management to set clear plans for the return to in-person college. This blueprint of leaving the basics of curriculum improvement to the states whereas offering greatest practices and instruments and concentrating on funding to realize massive nationwide objectives is strictly what we’d like going ahead.
The division would have one other secret weapon because it transitions to a broader competitiveness remit: neighborhood faculties.
Over 30 states provide some type of free neighborhood faculty, with deep-red Tennessee main with one of many most profitable applications. Group faculties aren’t seen by a hyperpartisan lens. In truth, 55% of voters with an associates diploma voted Republican in 2024, in keeping with NBC Information exit polling.
Making neighborhood faculty extra reasonably priced additionally cuts down on the variety of college students who want federal monetary assist. Equipping neighborhood faculties with not simply the funds but in addition the strategic roadmap to supply world-class know-how choices can be a core focus of the Division of American Competitiveness.
In some ways, it is a painful technique for me to write down. A lifelong Democrat and alumnus of the Biden administration, I wish to see the federal authorities do extra to advertise accessibility and fairness in training. Having stated that, reimagining the division to architect and promote American innovation and competitiveness is a uncommon alternative for the Trump administration to deliver each side collectively round an enormous thought.
