Blake Energetic Stars and Justin Baldoni Directs

Colleen Hoover‘s 2016 novel — now tailored into an earnestly imperfect however nonetheless satisfyingly delicate movie — begins with narrator Lily Bloom (Blake Energetic) describing herself on a notice of satirically downbeat humor: She’s “that unusual lady with the erratic pink hair who as soon as fell in love with a homeless man and introduced nice disgrace upon her complete household.”

However that was in highschool. On this second she’s up on the rooftop of a deluxe Boston condominium constructing, the place she’s simply met Ryle Kincaid (Jane the Virgin’s Justin Baldoni, who additionally directs).

Ryle is the whole bundle, the golden ticket, the ship come into harbor: He’s an excellent neurosurgeon with smoldering attractiveness and an immaculately conditioned helmet of hair.

Lily has each proper to swoon, though she’s too cussed to offer in instantly. However she is going to. 

After which she’ll undergo. Why? As a result of Lily has but to totally reckon with the bodily and emotional abuse that she and her mom (Amy Morton) endured by the hands of her father (Kevin McKidd) again in Plethora, Maine. That’s an odd identify for a spot — Bountiful is perhaps nicer — however it’s indicative of an overabundance of points that may creep from her previous into the current, the place they’re going to threaten to wreck the longer term.

For some time Lily appears to thrive. She marries that dreamboat surgeon. She opens a profitable flower store, a comfy little house crowded with petals, crops, twigs and bric-a-brac. Speak about a plethora! You’ll be able to think about Queen Victoria and her royal entourage sweeping in, giving the place the once-over and taking dwelling just a few strands of ivy to brighten her commemorative bust of Prince Albert.

However maybe Lily ought to have seen how violently Ryle kicked a chair the night time they met….

Energetic’s efficiency may be very a lot within the fashion she established again in her Gossip Woman days: She has a willowy vulnerability, an intriguing air of distant unhappiness and a gentle, muffled voice that sounds as if she have been talking from inside a pile of autumn leaves. 

She’s a stunning, gifted actress, and a bit like Gwyneth Paltrow — besides that Paltrow can reduce via a second with sudden, deep flashes of perception. Energetic is extra modest, however she’s in all probability additionally the precise actress for this film, which has a soothing gauziness regardless of the underlying toughness of its story. 

It additionally has a passive indifference to concrete element that may let the narrative slip. When a key character from Lily’s previous exhibits up at her desk in a flowery Boston restaurant, it’s not clear whether or not he’s the proprietor, the chef or only a waiter with a wierd air of intimacy. If he requested you about allergy symptoms, you would possibly suppose he was attempting to insinuate one thing.

In actual fact that is Atlas (1923’s Brandon Sklenar), the grown-up model of that homeless boy Lily as soon as beloved. His arrival — when you grasp who he’s — seems to be a deft plot machine that propels the story to a brand new stage of disaster and, lastly, a touching conclusion.

Though right here, too, Blake appears to carry again from delivering the total dramatic weight of the confrontation that permits Lily to lastly break with the previous. Not that she wants or must be hovering excessive — depart that to Emma Stone in no matter Yorgos Lanthimos film she’s starring in in the intervening time. However the scene may have been a corker.

It is probably price evaluating Ends with Priscilla, Sofia Coppola’s 2023 movie about Priscilla Presley (Cailee Spaeny) and her suffocating marriage to Elvis. That movie was, like Ends, a portrait of an emotionally inert younger girl who slowly comprehends the falseness of her life. However you by no means anticipated Priscilla to behave in another way in any given second of her evolution, so assured was Coppola’s quiet authority at sustaining tone.

By no means miss a narrative — join PEOPLE’s free day by day e-newsletter to remain up-to-date on one of the best of what PEOPLE has to supply, from juicy superstar information to forcing human curiosity tales.

Right here you end up distracted by Energetic’s fashionable intelligence. Even carrying a pair of overalls, she may get fairly a means up the pink carpet on the Met Gala earlier than being turned again.

Ends, it needs to be mentioned, is at its finest when it flashes again to the previous, the place Isabela Ferrer is the younger Lily and Alex Neustaedter the younger Atlas. (Ferrer is an ideal bodily match for Energetic. Neustaedter and Sklenar don’t look as in the event that they share a single chromosome.) This teenage romance has the real urgency of adolescent distress, which (you could or might recall) stings with its unanticipated newness and might’t be relieved by wanting ahead to the day that you just blossom into Blake Energetic. 

Jenny Slate, as Lily’s wealthy sister-in-law, sidles out and in of the film in her shrewdly comedian means — candy but barely subversive. She’s a cupcake recent from the bakery in your unconscious thoughts.

It Ends With Us is in theaters now.