In at this time’s concern, Ben Harper from Luxor Know-how gives an replace on what’s taking place with bitcoin mining this yr.
Then, Colin Harper from Blockspace Media solutions questions on the subject of mining and AI in Ask and Skilled.
You’re studying Crypto for Advisors, CoinDesk’s weekly e-newsletter that unpacks digital belongings for monetary advisors. Subscribe right here to get it each Thursday.
Bitcoin Mining Has Modified — It’s No Longer Simply In regards to the Value
The bitcoin mining funding thesis was easy — miners thrived when bitcoin’s value soared, and when it fell, they suffered. However in 2024, that equation modified. Bitcoin ETFs, hashrate markets and AI have essentially reshaped the business, lowering miners’ dependence on bitcoin’s value. Right here’s why mining is now not only a guess on bitcoin, and what this implies for buyers.
2024: The Yr Bitcoin Mining Diverged From Bitcoin’s Value
In 2023, Bitcoin mining shares behaved like a high-beta proxy for Bitcoin, amplifying its strikes — hovering larger when bitcoin rallied and crashing more durable when it fell. However in 2024, this sample broke down. Regardless of bitcoin reaching new all-time highs, mining shares did not reclaim their earlier peaks.
The desk under illustrates the shifting correlation between Hashrate Index’s Crypto Mining Index and bitcoin’s value, evaluating weekly costs and returns earlier than and through 2024:
Supply: Hashrate Index, June 2020 – December 2024
The takeaway is evident: Bitcoin mining shares are now not only a easy guess on bitcoin’s value. This divergence stems from 4 key developments shaping the sector:
1. Institutional Bitcoin Adoption: The Creation of Spot ETFs
The launch of spot bitcoin ETFs in January 2024 reshaped institutional funding in bitcoin. With ETFs amassing over 1.3 million BTC and surpassing $100 billion in belongings underneath administration, the enchantment of mining shares as a bitcoin proxy pale. As a substitute of utilizing miners as an oblique publicity, capital flowed straight into Bitcoin by way of ETFs, essentially shifting market dynamics.
2. The Halving and Its Aftermath: A Squeeze on Miner Economics
Bitcoin’s fourth halving in April 2024 reduce the block subsidy from 6.25 BTC to three.125 BTC per block, slashing miners’ major income supply in half. Traditionally, post-halving bitcoin value surges have helped offset decrease rewards, however this time, miners confronted extra headwinds:
- Report-high community issue. Rising competitors lowered particular person miner rewards.
- Falling transaction charges. Decrease demand for blockspace diminished a vital secondary income stream.
- Hashprice collapse. Regardless of bitcoin’s rally, hashprice, an all-in measure of mining income per unit of computation (i.e., hashrate), plummeted 75%.
Whereas bitcoin’s value soared 120% all year long, miners struggled to take care of profitability, resulting in consolidation and strategic pivots inside the business.
Supply: Hashrate Index
3. The Rise of Hashrate Derivatives: A Recreation-Changer for Miners
One of the vital vital monetary developments in bitcoin mining in 2024 was the speedy enlargement of the hashrate derivatives market. This rising market allowed miners to hedge future income streams and cut back publicity to bitcoin value volatility, essentially altering how they handle threat.
Historically, mining revenues had been on the mercy of bitcoin’s each day value swings, making it troublesome for operators to forecast money flows or safe financing. Nevertheless, with the rise of hashrate ahead markets, miners may promote future hashrate manufacturing at a hard and fast value, locking in income months prematurely. This monetary instrument capabilities equally to commodity futures within the vitality sector, the place electrical energy producers pre-sell energy contracts to stabilize revenue.
In 2024, these once-nascent markets noticed explosive development. Over-the-counter (OTC) volumes surged greater than 500% year-over-year on Luxor’s hashrate ahead market, with contract durations extending as much as 12 months. In the meantime, regulated change buying and selling took a significant step ahead with Bitnomial launching hashrate futures, making it the primary regulated change to supply a bitcoin mining by-product product.
The maturation of hashrate ahead markets indicators a brand new period in mining finance — one the place miners have larger management over their income streams, higher entry to capital, and improved resilience in opposition to bitcoin value volatility.
4. Bitcoin Mining Meets AI & HPC: A Convergence of Industries
With mining income underneath strain, many corporations are pivoting to AI and high-performance computing (HPC) to diversify income. Bitcoin mining infrastructure shares key similarities with AI knowledge facilities — each require huge energy and cooling capability. Nevertheless, the shift isn’t simple: AI infrastructure is costlier per megawatt (thousands and thousands vs. a whole bunch of 1000’s for bitcoin mining), requiring vital capital funding.
Some miners are embracing hybrid fashions, allocating a few of their computing energy to AI workloads whereas sustaining bitcoin mining operations. Corporations like HIVE Digital Applied sciences, Hut 8, Core Scientific, and Bit Digital have already made the leap, securing profitable AI contracts to develop and stabilize their money flows.
Last Ideas
Bitcoin mining in 2025 is now not nearly bitcoin’s value. Institutional capital, hashrate derivatives and AI-driven diversification are reshaping the business, giving miners new instruments to handle threat and optimize income. On the similar time, post-halving pressures, rising competitors and infrastructure prices have made effectivity and flexibility extra essential than ever.
For buyers and advisors, understanding these shifts is crucial. Mining shares now not transfer in lockstep with bitcoin, and new monetary devices are altering how miners function. Because the business continues to mature, those that acknowledge these structural modifications can be higher positioned to navigate the alternatives forward.
– Ben Harper, director, Luxor Know-how
Ask an Skilled
Are bitcoin miners really severe about breaking into the AI market?
Completely. Since 2022, bitcoin miners have been more and more exploring AI and high-performance compute (HPC) enterprise strains. A number of the earliest movers on this shift had been Hut 8, Hive, IREN, Core Scientific and Bit Digital. Extra just lately, Riot put its 600 MW enlargement at Corsicana on pause to guage the location for AI load, Cipher obtained a $50 million funding from SoftBank for its personal AI challenge, and Lancium and Crusoe Power are constructing a multi-gigawatt campus for AI as a part of Challenge Stargate.
How will bitcoin miners deal with their AI transitions? Is there a one-size-fits-all method?
AI/HPC methods range from miner to miner. Hut 8 and Bit Digital, for instance, have opted to amass present knowledge heart companies quite than construct their very own knowledge facilities from scratch or retrofit present infrastructure. Core Scientific, however, is changing the large energy belongings and infrastructure it has readily available for AI/HPC load in its partnership with CoreWeave (Riot may observe an identical mannequin ought to it resolve to transform parts of its Corsicana campus into an AI knowledge heart). And others, like Hive and IREN, have bought GPUs to function AI/HPC cloud providers inside their present services. Every of those methods have tradeoffs (the Hut 8 and Bit Digital mannequin are low threat, low reward, whereas Core Scientific’s method is excessive threat, excessive reward), and we can have a greater concept of which method is essentially the most profitable over the subsequent few years.
With robust market demand for AI, will bitcoin miners nonetheless mine bitcoin?
For now, loads of bitcoin miners — together with MARA, Cleanspark and Bitfarms — are nonetheless specializing in bitcoin mining as a substitute of chasing the AI/HPC golden rabbit. Even when bitcoin miners convert components of their infrastructure into AI/HPC load, they are going to probably nonetheless mine bitcoin, even when they cut back their deal with this pursuit. Finally, bitcoin mining and AI/HPC are extra complementary than aggressive, as miners can use bitcoin mining to monetize vitality that they’ve already paid for when AI/HPC demand is low.
– Colin Harper, editor-in-chief, Blockspace Media
Maintain Studying
