In case you are carrying mild hundreds (or your bike would not have pannier rack mounts) then you possibly can simply get away with one of many greatest biking backpacks. For bigger hundreds, and even simply to keep away from a sweaty again, the common-or-garden bicycle pannier is an ideal and effectively developed system.
Additionally it is my agency perception that the pannier is superior in all respects moreover weight to one of the best bikepacking baggage. Larger capability, simpler to pack, no wobble, no straps to rub your body. They’re additionally far simpler for smaller riders to make use of, as there is no such thing as a concern of clearance between saddle and rear tyre. There is a cause the pannier has been adopted so broadly by customers and commuters to round-the-world explorers.
Provided that panniers have been round for donkey’s years there are a tonne of choices on the market. Some are higher for the each day commute, some for heading off for a month on two wheels, and plenty of are nice do-it-all choices.
If you happen to’re caught, head to the underside of the web page the place I’ve put collectively a useful information to assist.
Fast checklist
The perfect do-it-all possibility. Sturdy, waterproof, dependable. Will stand you in good stead for attending to the workplace or heading off on an journey.
Elops Waterproof Bike Bag 900
For the value, it is onerous to beat. A bit thinner than the Ortlieb, however massive capability, simple setup, and an aesthetic that is extra premium than many costlier choices.
All-round reflectivity, plus mounts for lights on either side for max visibility. Not the largest, however sufficiently big for attending to and from work.
Only a massive ol’ plastic tub. Its simplicity is its power and makes it excellent for purchasing runs the place you possibly can simply chuck issues in. There is a web for the highest, too.
Sure, this is not a pannier. If you need correct crash safety to your laptop computer then ditch the in-built sleeve and simply use a devoted laptop computer case as a substitute.
The Pedal-Mate is an honest pannier in its personal proper however features a pocket particularly designed to hold an e-bike battery. Excellent when you want a spare, or take yours with you.
The perfect bike panniers you should purchase right this moment
You possibly can belief Cyclingnews
Our consultants spend numerous hours testing biking tech and can all the time share sincere, unbiased recommendation that can assist you select. Discover out extra about how we check.
Greatest General
1. Ortlieb Again-Curler
Greatest General
Specs
Waterproof: Sure
Laptop computer Sleeve: Sure – Small
Instruments Wanted: No
Capability: 20L
Mild Mounts: No
Color Choices: Black, white, orange, purple, yellow, gray, blue, high-vis yellow, hi-vis black
Reflective Particulars: Patches entrance and rear
Causes to purchase
Software-free set up
+Gold-standard waterproofing
+Myriad color choices
Causes to keep away from
Bit floppy when empty
–The strap generally is a bit fiddly
–Pairs just for color choices
There’s each likelihood that once you consider a bicycle pannier you might be picturing certainly one of these. The Ortlieb Again curler is the archetypal pannier and can serve you effectively when you’re commuting or when you’re bike touring.
The outside is a brightly colored, rubberised canvas on the entrance, with black on the perimeters that has just a little extra flex to it. It’s only a void with little in the way in which of organisation save for a laptop computer sleeve and just a little zipped mesh pocket for valuables, and as will develop into a theme my recommendation is to only use a devoted laptop computer sleeve.
Setup is an absolute breeze, with no instruments wanted in any respect. The 2 higher clips are on toothed sliding rails, so the bag will be unclipped, slid, and reclipped to adapt to completely different racks, and the decrease stabiliser bar is moved and tightened by hand.
It is just a little floppy when not full, however that is a criticism that may be levelled towards many on this checklist. As soon as plumped out it is loads shapely, and the reflective particulars entrance and rear are decently sized too.
The strap which holds the rolltop closure (the one option to go for true waterproof-ness) down additionally doubles as a shoulder strap. It is just a little fiddly to arrange, but it surely’s generously lengthy and simple sufficient to hold to get you up the workplace stairs.
Annoyingly if you would like a single pannier you possibly can solely have it in black – the colorful choices are solely bought as pairs, and 40 litres is just too a lot for commuting hundreds.
Greatest Funds
2. Elops 27L Waterproof Bike Bag 900
Greatest Funds Pannier
Specs
Waterproof: Sure
Laptop computer Sleeve: No
Instruments Wanted: Screwdriver
Capability: 27L
Mild Mounts: Entrance and rear
Color Choices: Sage inexperienced, yellow, black
Reflective Particulars: No
Causes to purchase
Large worth on provide
+Cheerful aesthetic
+Mild mounts
Causes to keep away from
No laptop computer sleeve
–Supplies fairly skinny
The Elops is from Decathlon’s ever-increasing and ever-improving lineup of biking merchandise. It is excellent when you’re on a price range, and on the time of writing it is decreased too so it is much more of a cut price.
Like many of the rolltop choices, it is a easy void, and just a little bigger than the Ortlieb. The fabric of the primary physique is just a little thinner feeling although, and as there is no such thing as a reinforcement on the underside there could also be longevity points if these get heavy use, both for touring or commuting.
The KLICKfix mount system is similar as discovered on many extra premium choices and works effectively, although does want a screwdriver to arrange. It will match all rack sizes with none adapters, however you should keep in mind to press the purple lock button underneath to carry it in place securely.
In addition to no decrease reinforcement there aren’t any shoulder straps, and the carry deal with is fairly skinny. You may in all probability find yourself cradling it like a brown paper bag of groceries to get to your desk, however such is the value to pay for netting a cut price.
Greatest For Commuting
3. Altura Thunderstorm Metropolis
Greatest bike pannier for commuting
Specs
Waterproof: Sure
Laptop computer Sleeve: Sure – Small
Instruments Wanted: Screwdriver
Capability: 20L
Mild Mounts: Entrance and rear
Color Choices: Black, hi-vis yellow
Reflective Particulars: Sure
Causes to purchase
All-over reflective particulars
+Mild mounts entrance and rear too
+Excellent commuting capability
Causes to keep away from
Semi-sewn closure makes stuffing it just a little tougher
–Listed closure means the rolltop will be unfastened
After I say ‘greatest for commuting’ I imply primarily that this has essentially the most reflective detailing. My check unit got here in black, however if you would like essentially the most visibility then I feel it’s best to go for the high-vis yellow possibility. It nonetheless has the identical reflective particulars, however… is shiny yellow too.
It is one other drybag-style possibility, however you do get a sleeve for a small laptop computer. the 20-litre capability is the candy spot for commuting too. Sufficient for a laptop computer, change of garments, toiletries, and lunch.
The closure on the high is barely sewn shut, in order to assist the rolltop fold down, but it surely makes stuffing it with issues just a little extra difficult, and in case you have a big laptop computer you would possibly battle.
Rolltops are nice, particularly for preserving water out, and never having plastic buckles is one much less factor to interrupt, however an listed, non-adjustable hook and loop ladder closure means you will be between positions, leaving the rolltop just a little unfastened.
The higher hooks additionally haven’t any adjustment, although ought to match nearly all of racks with no downside.
Greatest For Laptops
4. Mous laptop computer case
Greatest for laptops
Specs
Waterproof: No
Laptop computer Sleeve: Sure
Instruments Wanted: None
Capability: 1 Laptop computer
Mild Mounts: No
Color Choices: Many
Reflective Particulars: No, that may be odd
Causes to keep away from
Is an extra buy
I exploit an enormous MacBook for work, so typically talking many of the laptop computer sleeves in panniers are too small for me anyway. Regardless, the safety provided by panniers that do have laptop computer sleeves is comparatively minimal.
My recommendation if you wish to shield your laptop computer is to only use a devoted laptop computer sleeve. I exploit one from Mous, a model maybe higher identified for making tremendous protecting cellphone circumstances. The within is lined with a non-newtonian foam that hardens as higher drive (i.e. an influence) is utilized.
There are myriad choices in the marketplace, and one of the best guess is to search out one suited to your personal laptops dimensions. Your laptop computer can be susceptible to shifting about just a little extra, however this may be overcome if you’re anxious by the even handed software of sticky-backed Velcro to the sleeve and the within of the pannier.
In actuality, although I’ve discovered a pannier that has my workplace clothes in additional than retains it in place for my commutes.
Greatest For Buying
5. Specialised Coolcave
Greatest bike pannier for purchasing
Specs
Waterproof: No
Laptop computer Sleeve: No
Instruments Wanted: Screwdriver
Capability: 19L
Mild Mounts: No
Color Choices: Black
Reflective Particulars: No
Causes to purchase
Simple to throw issues into
+Can retailer tall objects (baguettes)
Causes to keep away from
Clearly every thing will get moist if it rains
The power of the Specialised Coolcave is its simplicity; it is only a plastic bucket, with the one further function being a clip-on elastic web to go excessive. If you happen to’re residing #CarFree and do your purchasing by bike then that is definitely a superb possibility, and greater than most works as a fit-and-forget everlasting addition to a utility bike.
Given its rigidity, and lack of padding, I would not actually counsel it really works as a stable commuter possibility, and because it has no lid then rain will naturally cowl your contents. There aren’t any drainage holes both, so do not go away it out within the rain for too lengthy otherwise you’ll find yourself with a small puddle sloshing about.
If you happen to’re shopping for baguettes, leeks, or something longer than would ordinarily go right into a pannier then that is the place you have to be trying.
Greatest For E-Bikes
6. Ortlieb Pedal-Mate
Greatest bike pannier for ebikes
Specs
Waterproof: Sure
Laptop computer Sleeve: No
Instruments Wanted: None
Capability: 16L
Mild Mounts: No
Color Choices: Blue, black, brown
Reflective Particulars: Sure
Causes to purchase
Devoted battery compartment
+The boxy form holds out even when empty
Causes to keep away from
Small capability, particularly with battery in
The Pedal-Mate (additionally generally listed because the E-Mate) is a devoted e-bike pannier. It is essentially the most boxy of the bunch on check, and holds its form even when empty (it is empty on this image), with extra of a lid than a flap.
Like the opposite Ortlieb choices on check, the set up is tool-free, so there’s zero danger of rounding off any small screw heads.
As a common use pannier I do not assume it is fairly sufficiently big. 16 litres is just a little on the small aspect for a commute generally, however when you’re driving with an e-bike and both need to retailer a spare battery for additional vary, otherwise you take your battery with you once you park up for safety causes it is definitely a greater resolution than having it unfastened in a typical pannier.
The shoulder strap, in contrast to the remainder of the Ortlieb panniers right here, is removable and would not kind a part of the closure mechanism, so when you have a tendency to depart the pannier connected to the bike on a regular basis you possibly can simply take it off for a cleaner look.
Additionally Examined
7. Ortlieb Again-Curler XL Plus
Largest bike pannier
Specs
Waterproof: Sure
Laptop computer Sleeve: No
Instruments Wanted: None
Capability: 35L
Mild Mounts: No
Color Choices: Black, purple/orange
Reflective Particulars: Sure
Causes to purchase
Huge capability
+Additional mesh pocket for moist issues
+Software-free set up
Causes to keep away from
Pair solely
–Costly
–Too massive for common use
The Again-Curler XL Plus is the larger model of the Again-Curler XL, which itself is the bigger model of the Again-Curler. It’s large, and as you possibly can solely purchase a pair of them you might be getting 70 litres of capability, which is kind of the identical as giant climbing backpacks or decent-sized suitcases.
This capability is bolstered by an increasing mesh pocket, into which you’ll be able to stow stuff you need simple handy, or moist garments.
These are firmly a long-distance, high-capacity possibility. They’re just too massive for commuting, evidenced by the dearth of a laptop computer sleeve inside.
The mounting is similar for the Again-Curler, although. No instruments are required, and the identical sturdy strap doubles as a shoulder service. The fabric is just a little thinner than that of the Again-Curler, presumably as a way to preserve the burden down.
With panniers this huge you should take note of the utmost weight allowances of your rear rack, in addition to the whole system weight allowances to your body and rear wheel. If you happen to aren’t utilizing the most effective touring bikes with a full pair of those it might not have the ability to address the torsion on the body, leading to some fairly horrible dealing with and security implications.
8. Tailfin system
Greatest bike panniers for bikepacking
Specs
Waterproof: Sure
Laptop computer Sleeve: No
Instruments Wanted: Hex keys
Capability: Varied
Mild Mounts: Sure
Color Choices: Black
Reflective Particulars: Sure
Causes to purchase
Modular
+No rack mounts wanted
+Aero and light-weight
Causes to keep away from
Extra fiddly than a typical pannier system
–Can induce velocity wobbles
The Tailfin AeroPack system is great. I’ve used it for bikepacking journeys prior to now, and that is the place it excels. The modularity is sensible, permitting you to make use of simply the highest aero pack bag, or add additional capability with clip-on baggage on the aspect, and even bottles when you want additional hydration.
The system is mild, and given the load sits principally behind your physique it is essentially the most aero possibility on the market. It additionally would not require that your bike has pannier mounts, although it does work with them if it does. This makes it excellent for including to race bikes, or mountain bikes and has been used to nice impact on the largest extremely races on the planet.
A phrase of warning although: Do try to pack mild, and steadiness the load. On bikes not designed to deal with hundreds the system can induce velocity wobbles as a result of added inertia on the rear. That is massively improved by balancing the rear load with some over the entrance, with both a big bar bag, fork packs, or each.
9. Carradice Tremendous C
Greatest bike panniers for traditional bikes
Specs
Waterproof: No
Laptop computer Sleeve: No
Instruments Wanted: Screwdriver
Capability: 27L
Mild Mounts: No
Color Choices: Black
Reflective Particulars: Sure
Causes to purchase
Unimaginable traditional vibes
+Will age fantastically
+Repairable
I’m an unashamed Carradice fan. I exploit its saddlebags commonly, and provided that my pannier-enabled bike is of a sure aesthetic – canti brakes, Brooks saddle, downtube shifters, metal and so forth – driving with a pannier fabricated from waxed canvas over plastic feels proper.
The Tremendous C vary is the model’s touring stuff and solely is available in black. The outer is cotton duck, a hardy canvas that has been waxed to maintain the water out. It is not formally waterproof, however when it will get moist the material swells barely and the pores shut up and it turns into fairly near waterproof, simply sufficient to shrug off a bathe, however not a sustained drenching.
Inside is only a void, with a drawstring high. The lid straps are generously lengthy so you possibly can stuff it tremendous full if wants be, and the extra pocket on the rear is sweet for spares.
The perfect factor for me, moreover the aesthetics, is the truth that it is reparable. Any holes will be sewn up, they are often rewaxed simply with a hairdryer and a few Fjallraven Greenland Wax, and you’ll add patches to them to make them your personal. They can even look higher with age because the creases of many miles mattress in, the alternative to the remaining on this checklist.
10. Revelate Designs Nano Panniers
Greatest light-weight panniers
Specs
Waterproof: No
Laptop computer Sleeve: No
Instruments Wanted: None
Capability: 9L
Mild Mounts: No
Color Choices: Gray
Reflective Particulars: No
Causes to purchase
Superlight
+Versatile mounting system
Causes to keep away from
Not waterproof
–Velcro mounts
If you happen to’re into packing mild, and the tailfin system is just a bit too cumbersome for you, then Revelate Designs’ Nano Panniers could possibly be those to take a look at. At between 7 and 11 litres, relying on how stuffed they’re, they’re simply the smallest on check, and positively for mild packers. Revelate additionally makes some superlight packing pouches that can assist you organise too.
The outer material is a light-weight polyester, and whereas they don’t seem to be waterproof there are only a few seams and the decrease seams are double taped to withstand spray from the wheels and add sturdiness.
In an effort to save weight there aren’t any heavy stable plastic mounts, only a pair of velcro straps on the high and a Voile strap to rigidity the system on the base. Velcro is not my favorite as it’s going to finally put on out and may gum up with crud, however this hook and loop is allegedly good for 10,000+ cycles, which must be greater than sufficient.
Not a commuting possibility actually, however for including further light-weight capability to a bikepacking setup they are often wonderful, particularly paired with a superlight titanium pannier rack.
11. Specialised Tailwind
An aero bike pannier
Specs
Waterproof: Sure
Laptop computer Sleeve: Sure – 17″
Instruments Wanted: Screwdriver
Capability: 17L
Mild Mounts: No
Color Choices: Black, high-vis yellow
Reflective Particulars: Sure
Causes to purchase
It is aero
+Trendy aesthetic
Causes to keep away from
Small in dimension
–Small opening
Air resistance would not simply swap off since you’re commuting, so why not get an aero pannier? The Specialised Tailwind is left/proper particular due to a easy, rounded vanguard devoid of any seams.
In addition to bettering your velocity on a standard bike, being a bit extra aero can even enhance the vary of your e-bike too, if that is a consideration.
The entire thing is boxy, and holds its form effectively even when empty (it is empty within the image), in order to remain aero on a regular basis. The closure is a water-resistant zip, and you’ll match a laptop computer as much as 17″ within the inside sleeve.
Aero comes at a worth although, and 17L is just a little on the small dimension, so both pack mild or spec a pair. The closure is simply on the highest and rear edge, too, so packing is a little more tough in comparison with panniers which have massive rolltop closures.
12. Restrap Pannier Giant
One other stable touring possibility
Specs
Waterproof: Sure
Laptop computer Sleeve: No
Instruments Wanted: Screwdriver
Capability: 22L
Mild Mounts: No
Color Choices: Black, olive
Reflective Particulars: Sure
Causes to purchase
Large void
+Bigger capability than Again-Curler
Causes to keep away from
Floppy when unladen
–Can foul on derailleur
The big Restrap Pannier is one other nice possibility that’s greatest suited to tourers fairly than commuters. The bag is a void, devoid of any organisation, in a lot the identical approach because the Carradice Tremendous C, and with an analogous type of aesthetic however with fashionable supplies.
The bag is actually floppy when unladen, and the fabric is much more versatile than it seems in images.
These positively match an analogous market phase to the Ortlieb Again-Curler, however the further capability, particularly for a pair, can be of profit to some and is an efficient bridge earlier than going to one thing just like the Again-Rller XL Plus.
It is a actually well-made bag, made within the UK if that’s of any curiosity, with an enormous, stable bumper on the rear to guard the bag from the place it rubs on the pannier rack.
The restrap mounts the bottom of all the baggage on check, a lot in order that on my rack it was in peril of fouling on my rear derailleur, so be certain when you go for these that you’ve a tall sufficient rear rack.
13. Thule Paramount Pannier
Each a backpack and a pannier in a single
Specs
Waterproof: Sure, with waterproof cowl
Laptop computer Sleeve: Sure – 16″
Instruments Wanted: No
Capability: 26L
Mild Mounts: Sure
Color Choices: Black, olive, tan
Reflective Particulars: Reflective cowl
Causes to purchase
Real 2-in-1 performance
+Loads of organisation
Causes to keep away from
Large dimension for small major compartment
I’m an unashamed pannier evangelist, however they’re a little bit of a ache to lug round off the bike. In case your commute includes some extra prolonged durations of time without work the bike then the Thule Paramount Pannier might effectively be an ideal resolution. You should utilize it as a pannier to get to a practice station for instance, after which with a fast flip of the rear panel, you possibly can put on it as a backpack for the remainder of the day.
There’s a tonne of organisational pockets, and area for a big laptop computer and a pill too, although all this organisation does barely cut back the scale of the primary compartment so the 26-litre capability is just a little deceptive. If you happen to’re a poorly organised stuffer then this could be kill or remedy for you.
The transformation is fairly simple from one to the opposite – a easy zip means it may be carried out in a matter of seconds. Once more, the mechanism does eat into the inner capability a bit, so the entire bag is bigger than many choices with related capability, however not one of the others will be worn in your again.
It is comparatively climate sealed, however not completely waterproof. In just a little pocket beneath although resides a totally reflective waterproof cowl for when the heavens open, or for once you simply need to be extra seen.
14. Topeak Drybag Pannier
Quickest to setup
Specs
Waterproof: Sure
Laptop computer Sleeve: No
Instruments Wanted: None
Capability: 16L
Mild Mounts: No
Color Choices: Black
Reflective Particulars: Sure
Causes to purchase
Simple and quick set up
+Actually stable buckles
+Thick materials
Causes to keep away from
On the smaller dimension
–No adjustment means it might foul on some racks
If you happen to’re consistently in a rush, otherwise you merely can’t be bothered with the reasonable faff of organising pannier clips from the field then the Topeak Drybag pannier is the way in which to go. It has no adjustment on the highest clips. Merely elevate it out of its packaging, drop it onto your rack, and away you go. The supporting decrease bar adjusts with the press of a button too.
Because the clips do not slide it might stumble upon some bits on some racks, however they’re narrowly spaced so it is unlikely to be a difficulty for many setups.
The pannier itself is boxy and feels extraordinarily stable. The fabric is thicker than most, with externally welded seams, and an honest bumper to guard it from rubbing on a derailleur/bolt heads.
The buckles on the aspect are additionally among the greatest I’ve come throughout. Cumbersome and stable, however simple to make use of, with a locking mechanism for the straps to make sure they do not slip when it is stuffed full.
The 16-litre capability is on the smaller finish of the scale spectrum, however when you’re an environment friendly packer then it is definitely an possibility.
14. Brooks Scape
Traditional seems to be with fashionable tech
Specs
Waterproof: Sure
Laptop computer Sleeve: No
Instruments Wanted: Screwdriver
Capability: Sure
Mild Mounts: 20L
Color Choices: Black, inexperienced
Reflective Particulars: Sure
Causes to purchase
Stylish aesthetic
+Neat strap clips
+Outer pocket
Causes to keep away from
Feels just a little flimsy for the value
Brooks is a reputation you doubtless affiliate with its leather-based saddles – for good cause, it have to be stated – but it surely additionally does a line in classically styled baggage. Aesthetics has clearly been on the forefront, as even the KlickFix locking buttons which can be often purple have been swapped for gray right here to protect a sure look.
It is not all concerning the seems to be although. The Scape is a stable 20-litre pannier that matches the identical type of area of interest because the Again-Curler. It is only a void, with no inside organisation, although an exterior pocket for small objects is useful and far simpler to entry than an inside one.
The fabric feels fairly skinny nevertheless, an analogous thickness to the Elops bag, so I would be cautious of utilizing these when you’re significantly tough on tools. There’s a stable decrease bumper although, to guard it from tough floor.
The straps are a hook-and-loop association, although they are often cinched down, and the surplus strap will be rolled up and wrapped in a neat Velcro clip. I wasn’t an enormous fan of the carry deal with although, which is kind of skinny; one other one to cradle if it is closely laden.
The best way to Select
Selecting a set of, or a single pannier, is an funding. They are usually made fairly sturdy in order that they’ll doubtless be with you for a few years until you are significantly abusive. With that in thoughts it is key to get one thing that matches your wants, so be sincere about your use case.
There isn’t any level shopping for a 27-litre touring pannier when you’re commuting as soon as every week to the workplace, and conversely, there is no level shopping for a 16-litre commuter pannier when you’re planning on driving off into the sundown for 3 months.
How massive ought to a motorbike pannier be?
For commuting, something between 16 litres and 20 litres is about proper. Any smaller and also you danger not becoming in what I consider as ‘random contingency objects’, and any bigger and there can be a whole lot of lifeless area, which is annoying and will go away issues like your laptop computer slopping round over bumps.
What are one of the best panniers for touring?
If you happen to imply regular, run-of-the-mill touring then the Ortlieb Again-Curler is my decide. It is available in pairs, and a 40-litre mixed capability is ample, particularly when you bolster it with a bar bag. If you need extra then the Again-Curler XL Plus is about as massive as one can feasibly get, however until you are driving a devoted touring bike I would advise towards this as you possibly can simply overload the utmost system weight of a motorbike or the rear wheel.
Do panniers match all bikes?
Most panniers will match kind of any pannier rack – that is the simple bit. Not all bikes have the mandatory mounts for a correct, bolted-on pannier rack although. In recent times there are a higher variety of common choices that clip to thru-axles and your seatpost, opening up the world of panniers to extra riders.
Remember although, simply because you possibly can match a pannier rack to a motorbike does not imply it’s best to. Light-weight, race-oriented street and gravel bikes merely aren’t designed to have a big mass with a whole lot of inertia sitting behind the rider, which might impart a whole lot of torsion on a body.
Can I exploit panniers for bikepacking?
Completely. Personally I feel panniers are preferable to bikepacking baggage besides maybe over the roughest terrain the place straps coming unfastened is a much less unhealthy final result than bolts shearing off. For smaller riders, whose bikes merely haven’t got the identical area within the body or between the saddle and the rear wheel, panniers are a superb lifeline and should not be ignored as a result of they don’t seem to be ‘bike-packing-y’.
How a lot do bike panniers gradual you down?
When you’re up to the mark until you are driving uphill, the primary approach panniers maintain you again is thru aerodynamic drag – they do stick out way over a backpack or teardrop saddle bag. Uphill, too, there’s a penalty, as there’s when pulling away at lights.
When you hit cruising velocity they’re solely just a little bit slower than the options when you’re carrying an equal load, and for commuting and touring the consolation, simplicity, and lack of bag-wobble greater than make up for any velocity deficit.
